counterexamples-around-series-part-1-image

Counterexamples around series (part 1)

The purpose of this article is to provide some basic counterexamples on real series. Counterexamples are provided as answers to questions.

Unless otherwise stated, (un)nN and (vn)nN are two real sequences.

If (un) is non-increasing and converges to zero then un converges?

Is not true. A famous counterexample is the harmonic series 1n which doesn’t converge as 2pk=p+11k2pk=p+112p=1/2, for all pN.

If un=o(1/n) then un converges?

Does not hold as can be seen considering un=1nlnn for n2. Indeed x2dttlnt=ln(lnx)ln(ln2) and therefore 2dttlnt diverges. We conclude that 1nlnn diverges using the integral test. However nun=1lnn converges to zero.

If un=o(vn) and vn converges then un converges?

Is not true as we can see taking vn=(1)nn and un=1nlnn. vn converges according to the alternating series test and un diverges according to previous paragraph. However limn|unvn|=limn1lnn=0.

If un is a positive converging series then un+1un is bounded?

Not either. Have a look at un={1n2for n even12nfor n odd. Then for pN u2p+1u2p=22p+14p2 diverges to . However un converges as 1n2 and 12n both converge.

One thought on “Counterexamples around series (part 1)”

Leave a Reply