Category Archives: Algebra

An irreducible integral polynomial reducible over all finite prime fields

A classical way to prove that an integral polynomial QZ[X] is irreducible is to prove that Q is irreducible over a finite prime field Fp where p is a prime.

This raises the question whether an irreducible integral polynomial is irreducible over at least one finite prime field. The answer is negative and:
P(X)=X4+1 is a counterexample. Continue reading An irreducible integral polynomial reducible over all finite prime fields

A vector space written as a finite union of proper subspaces

We raise here the following question: “can a vector space E be written as a finite union of proper subspaces”?

Let’s consider the simplest case, i.e. writing E=V1V2 as a union of two proper subspaces. By hypothesis, one can find two non-zero vectors v1,v2 belonging respectively to V1V2 and V2V1. The relation v1+v2V1 leads to the contradiction v2=(v1+v2)v1V1 while supposing v1+v2V2 leads to the contradiction v1=(v1+v2)v2V2. Therefore, a vector space can never be written as a union of two proper subspaces.

We now analyze if a vector space can be written as a union of n3 proper subspaces. We’ll see that it is impossible when E is a vector space over an infinite field. But we’ll describe a counterexample of a vector space over the finite field Z2 written as a union of three proper subspaces. Continue reading A vector space written as a finite union of proper subspaces

A finitely generated soluble group isomorphic to a proper quotient group

Let Q2 be the ring of rational numbers of the form m2n with m,nZ and N=U(3,Q2) the group of unitriangular matrices of dimension 3 over Q2. Let t be the diagonal matrix with diagonal entries: 1,2,1 and put H=t,N. We will prove that H is finitely generated and that one of its quotient group G is isomorphic to a proper quotient group of G. Continue reading A finitely generated soluble group isomorphic to a proper quotient group

A (not finitely generated) group isomorphic to a proper quotient group

The basic question that we raise here is the following one: given a group G and a proper subgroup H (i.e. H{{1},G}, can G/H be isomorphic to G? A group G is said to be hopfian (after Heinz Hopf) if it is not isomorphic with a proper quotient group.

All finite groups are hopfian as |G/H|=|G|÷|H|. Also, all simple groups are hopfian as a simple group doesn’t have proper subgroups.

So we need to turn ourselves to infinite groups to uncover non hopfian groups. Continue reading A (not finitely generated) group isomorphic to a proper quotient group

Converse of Lagrange’s theorem does not hold

Lagrange’s theorem, states that for any finite group G, the order (number of elements) of every subgroup H of G divides the order of G (denoted by |G|).

Lagrange’s theorem raises the converse question as to whether every divisor d of the order of a group is the order of some subgroup. According to Cauchy’s theorem this is true when d is a prime.

However, this does not hold in general: given a finite group G and a divisor d of |G|, there does not necessarily exist a subgroup of G with order d. The alternating group G=A4, which has 12 elements has no subgroup of order 6. We prove it below. Continue reading Converse of Lagrange’s theorem does not hold

A module without a basis

Let’s start by recalling some background about modules.

Suppose that R is a ring and 1R is its multiplicative identity. A left R-module M consists of an abelian group (M,+) and an operation R×MM such that for all r,sR and x,yM, we have:

  1. r(x+y)=rx+ry ( is left-distributive over +)
  2. (r+s)x=rx+sx ( is right-distributive over +)
  3. (rs)x=r(sx)
  4. 1Rx=x

+ is the symbol for addition in both R and M.
If K is a field, M is K-vector space. It is well known that a vector space V is having a basis, i.e. a subset of linearly independent vectors that spans V.
Unlike for a vector space, a module doesn’t always have a basis. Continue reading A module without a basis

A vector space not isomorphic to its double dual

In this page F refers to a field. Given any vector space V over F, the dual space V is defined as the set of all linear functionals f:VF. The dual space V itself becomes a vector space over F when equipped with the following addition and scalar multiplication:
{(φ+ψ)(x)=φ(x)+ψ(x)(aφ)(x)=a(φ(x)) for all ϕ,ψV, xV, and aF.
There is a natural homomorphism Φ from V into the double dual V, defined by (Φ(v))(ϕ)=ϕ(v) for all vV, ϕV. This map Φ is always injective. Continue reading A vector space not isomorphic to its double dual

A field that can be ordered in two distinct ways

For a short reminder about ordered fields you can have a look to following post. We prove there that Q can be ordered in only one way.

That is also the case of R as R is a real-closed field. And one can prove that the only possible positive cone of a real-closed field is the subset of squares.

However Q(2) is a subfield of R that can be ordered in two distinct ways. Continue reading A field that can be ordered in two distinct ways