two-disjoint-closed-sets-with-distance-equal-to-zero-image

Two disjoint closed sets with distance equal to zero

We take a metric space (E,d) and consider two closed subsets A,B having a distance d(A,B) equal to zero. We raise the following question: can A and B be disjoint – AB=?

If A or B is compact, let’s say A, AB cannot be empty. The proof is quite simple. As d(A,B)=0, for all nN we can pick up (an,bn)A×B with d(an,bn)1n+1. As A is compact, we can find a subsequence of (an)nN converging to a point aA. Even if it means renumbering the subsequence, we can suppose that limn+an=a. As d(a,bn)d(a,an)+d(an,bn) and both terms of the right hand side of the inequality converge to zero, (bn)nN also converges to a. As B is supposed to be closed, we have aB and finally aAB.

So we have to turn ourselves to the case where A and B are not compact to find a counterexample. If E=Rn with n1 that means A and B unbounded.

An example in the real line

Take A={an=n;nN} and B={bm=m+1m+2;mN}. A and B are disjoint as if n=m+1m+2 and n=m we get the contradiction 1m+2=0 while if nm we get the contradiction 1|nm|=1m+2<1. However d(A,B)=0 because limn+d(anbn)=0.

An example in the real plane

Take A={(x,y);y1/x>0} and B={(x,0);x0}.
A and B are closed subsets of the real plane and their intersection is empty. The proof is left to the reader.

Leave a Reply